“Electrostatic painting provides a smooth and uniform finish to metal surfaces, whereas powder coats are thicker and more durable layers that can withstand harsh environmental conditions”
Electrostatic painting and powder coating both the processes use electrostatic deposition of the protective layer on the surface of substrate parts. The bonded layer provides corrosion resistance, wear resistance, chemical protection, and other several benefits. However, there are many aspects of electrostatic painting vs. powder coating; Coating is the dry process and painting is the wet coating process. Another main difference is the curing process, the electrostatic painting does not require thermal curing at high temperatures. On the other hand, the curing temperature of powder coating finishes ranges from 350 to 400°F, or even higher.
What is Electrostatic Painting?
Electrostatic painting is a solvent-based finishing process, where the substrates are either dipped into paint or sprayers coat them with the paint solution. Typically, water-soluble paints are used and they provide corrosion protection and desired aesthetics. The pigments or other additives in the paint strongly attach it through magnetic bonding that lasts several years. The positively charged paint from the spray interreacts with the negative molecule of the substrate surface. However, the paint might require maintenance over time.
Electrostatic painting process
The advanced system can automate the process of spraying pressurized- molecules with precise thickness control. An electrode near the exit point of the nozzle atomized the paint before spraying. On the other hand, the substrate is electrically grounded.
Electrostatic painting on metal parts
Typically, polyurethane, acrylic, epoxy, and polyester resins are used to formulate the paint as the base filler. Other pigments, curing agents, and secondary fillers are also used based on the requirements. Some common curing agents for electrostatic painting are amide, isocyanate, and arizidine.
Advantages of Electrostatic Painting
The main advantage of electrostatic painting includes its in-site application, especially in the context of electrostatic painting vs powder coating. Unlike powder coating, it can be cured at room temperature.
Fast and On-site Finish
The electrostatic painted parts are ready to use within a day. You can bring the sprayer system to the site and finish the parts. It is beneficial for finishing construction and architectural items on the installation site.
Uniform Finish and Protection
The paint bonds with the surface and eliminates the microscopic irregularities, defects, and surface porosity with a uniform adhesive layer. This finish protects the metal and plastic parts from corrosion and wear.
Cost-effective
The minimal wastage, absence of a thermal curing step, and process speed contribute to the cost-effectiveness of the electrostatic painting method.
Finishing of Complex Shapes
The nozzle can spray the paint uniformly across the substrate body. There is no litigation for geometrical complexity, angled surface, irregular contours, etc.
Disadvantages of Electrostatic Painting
- The nonmetallic surfaces require pre-treatment before applying the electrostatic painting to make them conductive. It adds additional time and cost.
- High skill level operatively can only ensure the paint uniformity and strong adhesion.
- This finish works best on relatively simple and uniform shapes. It is challenging ( or needs extra effort) for large or complex items.
- The paint solvent can release harmful volatile organic compounds (VOCs) into the air.
Try Prolean Now!
What is Powder Coating Finish?
Powder coating is a versatile surface finishing process that coats the mechanical parts with thermoplastic or thermoset-based resin powders using electrostatic deposition. Similar to electrostatic painting, the static charges bond the powder with the surface, but it is a dry coating process.
Powder coating mechanism
It makes the part’s surface tougher and more resistant to environments. Additionally, it also comes with various color options. The process is carried out by dipping the parts into electrically charged dry powder or spraying, followed by high-temperature curing.
Powder coating on automotive wheel
Both metallic and plastic parts can be coated with dry powders. However, not all plastics can be coated, their melting point needs to be higher than the curing temperature. Aluminum and its alloys are highly compatible with this process due to their conductivity. If you want to know more about this, you can read more about how to powder coat aluminum here.
Advantages of Powder Coating
Durable and Pleasing Aesthetic
Electrostatic powder coating lasts many years ( 5- 12 years), providing a destination for corrosion, weather, and chemicals. This is because of the strong magnetic bond and the coating layer’s stabilization with cutting. Consequently, you can choose red, black, brown, blue, green, and numerous other colors along with matte, gloss, and high-gloss textures.
Primer for Subsequent Painting
The powder coat layer is also used as the primer base for aesthetic painting. It aids in the paint adhesion and smooth surface texture.
Low Cost for Large Volume
In a single cycle, several parts can be dipped into the tank containing powder. Additionally, the setup consistently works without any significant changes for multiple batches. Therefore the finishing cost per part decreases for large volumes.
No VOCs Emission
The electrostatic powder coating process does not emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs) or other hazardous gases. Thus, it is human health and environmentally friendly.
Disadvantages of Powder Coating
- The sprayer or dipping tank, curing arrangements, and advanced control mechanism increase the installation cost for powder coat setup.
- The appearance customization is challenging as it requires the pre-mixing of color pigments with powder.
- Powder coating has a high curing temperature, which limits the temperature-sensitive work materials.
Durability of Electrostatic Painting vs Powder Coating
If we compare the head-to-head life span of these two coating methods, powder coating generally provides superior durability. It can last for 10+ with proper care and maintenance, whereas paints typically last 5-7 years. The powder coating is a dry process that includes thermal curing. The cured coat becomes tougher and highly resistant to water, moisture, soft chemicals, and other environmental conditions.
The outdoor applications utilize the powder coat finishing as they can protect the parts from UV-rays and harsh weather, furniture, auto parts, agricultural items, etc. Even for these applications, the finish lasts for many years without any fading.
Which Costs More? Electrostatic Painting or Powder Coating
The paints are less expensive than the powder coat finishing prices. The simple application process and minimal setups for electrostatic paint make the process simple and cheaper. On the other hand, the complex step for curing, powder cost, and relatively slower speed increase the cost. However, the quality and durability of powder coats justify the prices.
You can simply analyze the cost differences between the powder coating and painting by their typical price ranges. The powder coating costs from $ 20 to $100/hour, plus the material costs. On the other hand, a small painting gallon can be purchased in the range of $ 20 to 150. Then, it does not require any curing setup, just labor, and spryer cost. Meanwhile, the finishing speed is also fast for the painting.
Moreover, the cost-effectiveness depends on your parts specifications and requirements. Electrostatic painting is suitable for simple and on-site projects, whereas powder coating offers better long-term value due to its durability for complex and outdoor applications.
Read more: Anodizing vs Powder Coating
Try Prolean Now!
Custom Finish With Powder Coating at ProleanTech
Achieving the desired texture and aesthetic appearance with a powder coating finish requires a deep understanding of powder materials, expert operators, and advanced technology. The careful execution of each step, from powder mixing to curing, can only ensure the highest protection from the environment and a pleasing aesthetic.
If you are looking for a powder coating service to finish your parts, ProleanTech can be an ideal solution. Our advanced powder coating facility can finish CNC-machined, sheet metal, injection molded, die cast, and other manufactured parts according to your custom requirements, such as surface texture, color, roughness level, etc.
For further information and an accurate quote from our engineers, submit your design on our online portal!
Key Takeaways:
- The main difference between powder coating and painting is that powder coating uses dry powder cured under heat, whereas painting involves applying atomized liquid paint.
- The powder coating is not suitable for on-site applications, but electrostatic painting can be used on remote sites.
- Powder coat layers are more durable than painting as thermal curing stabilizes the magnetic bond of powder and surface molecules.
- For on-site and small volumes, electrostatic painting is cost-effective. On the other hand, powder coating costs are effective for small to large-scale production volumes.
0 Comments